In response to the decision of the
Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) to uphold Mr Rajendra Chaudhary's
appeal, the Secretary of the BMA, Mr Jeremy Strachan, made the
following statement:
"We are very disappointed with the
decision of the Employment Appeal Tribunal to uphold Mr Chaudhary's
appeal. A preliminary review of the EAT judgment suggests there may be
good grounds for a further appeal to the Court of Appeal. It remains
our view, supported by leading counsel, that there was insufficient
evidence before the original employment tribunal to justify a finding
of discrimination and that the BMA has been subjected to an unfair
stigma.
It is also worth pointing out that since
the original Tribunal decision two and a half years ago, we have
supported Mr Chaudhary against various NHS authorities on three racial
discrimination appeals and an employment tribunal at a cost of over �150,000.
The BMA takes accusations of racial
discrimination extremely seriously and has a good track record of
representing members who consider they have been discriminated against
on the grounds of race, gender, disability or sexual orientation.
The Association, in common with any large
organisation, is concerned to ensure that its policies and practices
do not unconsciously or accidentally discriminate against its members
or its staff, and has taken appropriate steps to implement this
policy.
Since 1 October 2003, BMA members with
work-related discrimination claims have been referred to an external
firm of solicitors � Irwin Mitchell. Their role is to determine
whether the member's case meets the BMA merit criterion (namely a
greater than 50 per cent chance of success) and if so, to provide
legal representation before an Employment Tribunal. Last year for
example Irwin Mitchell obtained substantial damages for four BMA
members in race discrimination cases and a further award in February
this year. An additional 22 racial discrimination claims are currently
being handled by the firm."
Other recent BMA action includes:
- Equal opportunity training for BMA
regional office staff
- " Dealing with Discrimination
" � written guidelines for BMA members
- A thorough ongoing review of all BMA
policies, procedures and services to ensure they are not directly
or indirectly discriminatory
- An Equal Opportunities Committee �
The EOC and the BMA Board of Medical Education are preparing a
report on barriers to career progression . The committee also
seeks to give a voice to often marginalised doctors through
interviews with those who feel they have been victims of the
system. A report on the findings is due to be published this
summer.